Metal Roofing Cost  VS.  Asphalt Shingles Cost


A roof does more than just protecting your house. It plays a significant role in the general outlook of your home as well as making your house more resilient, energy sufficient, and can also increase living space.

Whether you are a seasoned homeowner replacing your roof or a new homeowner installing a new roof, one question must come to your mind.How much will it cost?

Various factors are put into consideration when averaging the cost of roof installation, but on average, according to roofingcalc, you can expect metallic roofing to cost you between $5.50 and $15.50 per square foot. A metal shingle roof could cost you an average of between $7.50 and 12.50 per square foot. A standing seam metal roof could cost you an average of between $9.50 and $15-50 per square foot while installing.

Roof contractors measure roofs in squares; one square is equal to 100sq.ft. Roof contractors estimate their rate based on:

  • The complexity of your intended design
  • Type of roofing material
  • Underlayment and accessories
  • Flashing
  • Ventilation
  • Flashing
  • Amount of labor required
  • Scope of work
  • Size of the project

The cost of materials and labor in the city you live in also plays a significant role. For example, in an expensive coastal city like Seattle or Boston, you are likely to pay more for roof installation.

Singles are known for their reliability, ease of maintenance, and cost-effectiveness, making them the most popular roofing material in the market today. On the other hand, there is metal roofing, the second most popular. The popularity of metal as a roofing material is due to its durability, wide selection of styles to choose from, and longevity.

Shingle roofs are now evolving from their traditional look. Nowadays, they are being manufactured to mimic the look of wood shakes, slate, and tile. They are perfect for any home style. They can come with scalloped edges that are ideal for Victorian homes or a terra cotta look, perfect for a Mediterranean home.

Traditionally, metal roofs were made from tin panels, but with current metal roofing technology, they are now made from zinc, galvanized metals, aluminum, and even copper-tin alloys. Their various designs and color configurations and finishes make them suitable for less rustic, more refined structures, from east coast Victorians to California contemporaries.

To get the look you desire for your home, choose the material that will give you a style that is most appealing to you. This article will break things down for you, from the cost of the materials to the advantages and limitations of using them.

Cost of materials and installation cost

Understanding the cost of materials and installation cost gives you the confidence you need to negotiate with contractors and to get the best deals while shopping for materials, without sacrificing on quality.

Although the cost of roofing materials is high, the most significant cost factor in roof repair and installation is labor — also, small material orders of less than 300sq. It costs more because you are not given a wholesale discount.
If your roof has a sophisticated design, with multiple cuts up angles, sidewalls, dormers, or skylights, then your total roof installation cost will be higher, depending on the complexity of your design.

Paint also adds on to the total cost of installation. If you order your roofing materials without paint, you can expect to pay an extra $2 to $3 per-square-foot. To save on this, it is better to order your roofing materials pre-painted.

According to fixt, an average homeowner, installing shingles on a 1,500 -square-foot roof will part with between $6,000 and $14,000. This is, however, an average cost. It may vary depending on the design of your roof.

Angie's list puts the average of installing a metal roof at $16,500. It is essential to consider that although metal as a material is expensive, most of this average quotation account for labor costs. The next sub-topic on this article will help clarify the reason for the high cost of installing a metal roof a little better for you.

Why is the cost of installation of metal roofing higher than that of asphalt?

Metal roof costs more than asphalt.

This could be due to the quality of the material itself. Metal is more durable and can withstand harsh weather conditions without damage. The additional value it provides in its durability and elimination of maintenance costs could, therefore, be a contributing factor to its high price.

Metallic roofing requires many accessories

Metal roof installation requires more accessories than those needed when installing asphalt roofs. Accessories required in metal roofs include Rivets, screws, sealing tape, pipe flashers, the sealers, and many others.

Metallic roofing requires experienced labor

Fitting the metal plates involves expertise. For a durable, well-fitted roof, the installation process must be carried out with precision, care, and patience. Experienced labor costs a lot. Labor costs for metal roof averages at between $7.50 and $ 12.50.

Breathable underlayment

Breathable underlayment, which is essential in metal roofs, adds an extra $30-$40 to the cost of materials per square foot.

Prices to expect for various metal types:

1. Steel

Some conventional systems made with steel are:

I. G-90-Galvanised steel 

G-90- Galvanized Steel, also called hot-dip galvanized steel, is the most affordable. It is mainly used in low-end roofing applications such as garages, sheds, and lower-end industrial and agricultural applications. It is also used in some homes.

The sheets are coated with a thin layer of zinc oxide, which provides resistance to corrosion and protection from the elements. The sheets are generally finished with Kynar-500 paint. The paint is known for its high quality and longevity.

II. Galvalume Steel

Galvalume Steel has an aluminum-zinc alloy coating applied by a continuous hot-dip process. It offers long-lasting protection from corrosion from elements exposure and rusting. It is mostly used in the manufacture of standing seam steel panels, which are used in most higher-end residential houses and buildings.

III. Steel standing seam

Steel standing seam prices range from about $4 to$4.50 per square foot. They need to be cut and fabricated at the construction site or local sheet metal shop before they are installed. Installation cost averages from $11.00 per square foot, not including the cost of removing the old roof in cases of roof repair.

2. Aluminum

Aluminum is of higher quality and longevity than steel. It is the best option for homes near coastal areas as it provides more long-lasting protection from corrosion than steel.

Aluminum standing seam

Aluminum standing seam costs range from $4.00 to $6.00 per square foot. Before installation, they are cut to specified measurements. This can be done at the construction site, but it is preferable to do it at the sheet store to avoid the extra energy and labor cost.

Installation of aluminum standing seam costs about $12.00 per square foot, not putting into consideration the cost of removing your old roof.

3. Copper

Copper comes with a hefty price tag as it is a premium quality material. Copper costs an average of between $8.00 to $14.00 per square foot, not including the cost of removing the previous roof.

The cost of copper varies depending on the thickness of the metal planes. The price of installing copper standing seam planes is significantly higher as it requires soldering of the 16oz. Copper pans.

Another factor that makes metallic roofing significantly higher than shingle roofing is:

Paint and Finnish

Metal roof sheets come in a wide range of paint coatings varying in the grades-from low to premium quality. It is best to buy coated metal plates/sheets to avoid getting stuck with an unwarranted paint Finnish.

Although they cost more, painted roofing metal sheets provide superior protection from rust and corrosion from the elements than self-applied off-the shelf-paint. Besides, they are warranted hence eliminating extra cost in case of damage.

Advantages of using a metal roof


Metal roofs are environmentally friendly
Metal roofs last very long; hence do not require regular replacement. The superior longevity of metal and the fact that it does not require frequent replacement saves on wastage that could be otherwise harmful to the environment. Metal is also 100% recyclable.


Saves you money
Metal roofs have superior longevity, durability, and energy efficiency. Their ability to last long means you save money that you would otherwise have spent on replacement. The excellent energy efficiency of metal that allows your home to stay cool even in hot weather enables you to cut down on electricity bills as you don't need to use your air conditioner regularly.


Standing seam installation supports solar panels
Standing seam metal roofs provide space for seamless solar panels installation, thus boosting your energy-saving even more.

For more about metal roof advantages, watch this video.

Limitations of metallic roofing


Even though metal roofs last much longer, their cost is very high. The cost of a metal roof can be almost thrice as much like that of other materials.


Metal roofs are very noisy, especially during a hailstorm or heavy rain. The problem with noise can, however, be overcomed by installing insulation, at an extra cost.


Expansion and contraction
Metal roof materials attached as large panels may get loose due to constant expansion and contraction. This can be prevented by installing fasteners to allow "breathing" while the roof is being installed.

Asphalt shingles

The average cost of installing shingles is between$1.50 to $5.50, depending on the size, pitch, and slope of your roof. This is according to modernize.

When compared to other roofing materials, asphalt roofs are the most affordable. Their affordability makes them a common choice for many homeowners.


1. 3 Tab shingles

These are the commonly used shingles. They are distinguishable from other brands by tabs or cutouts that are made on their lower edges. The tabs make them look like three different pieces when placed on the roof, hence the name 3-tab. The cost of one 3-tab composition shingle is about $0.90 per square foot.

2. Architectural shingles

Architectural shingle's lower layers are laminated with an additional asphalt layer. The extra asphalt layer gives them a contoured, dimensional look. Asphalt sealants are added to reinforce the shingle's waterproof capability. Architectural shingles cost about $4.5 per square foot.

3. Synthetic shingles 

These synthetic luxury shingled roofs can replicate high-end roofing materials like cedar shark roofs and natural slate, at a much lower cost. A synthetic asphalt slate costs about $950 per square.

Advantages of shingles


Shingles can be adapted to different angles and shapes thus giving you a custom roofing solution


Design variety
Asphalt shingled roofs can be simulated to produce lavish architectural styles and designs at affordable prices.


Have a class A fire rating
Shingles with fiberglass have a class A fire rating. They offer protection against the spread and penetration of fire.


They offer sound protection
When included in your roofing system, shingles significantly reduce and dampen external noise.


Shingles are easy to install
Shingle roofing do not require as much expertise to install as metallic roofing does. However, for quality work, you should hire a well trained and reputable contractor.


Wide color variety to choose from
Shingles come in a wide variety of colors so you cannot miss one that fits your taste and curb appeal

You can see more examples here:

Limitations of asphalt shingles


Short lifespan
Depending on your level of maintenance and average weather conditions, an asphalt roof lasts about 30 years. After that, a replacement is required.


Susceptible to damage
Asphalt shingles are vulnerable to strong winds. Strong winds lift the shingles, thus loosening them from the roof structure. Stronger winds could even tear them off.


Mildew and moss issues
If your roof is not lit continuously by sunlight, it is susceptible to the growth of moss and mildew. According to Edward enterprises inc, it can be avoided by regularly cleaning your roof to remove all organic matter such as leaves.


When choosing the best roof replacement or merely a roof type when constructing a new home, it is essential to know all the facts about roofing materials and their prices. The knowledge of roofing enables you not only to find the best roofing material for your home but also to negotiate effectively with contractors.

There are many roofing materials in the market, the most common ones being those we have discussed. These roofing materials can give your house that customized look you desire; all you have to do is go for it. With all the knowledge that you have gained from this article, you are sure to make an informed decision.

Your decision will depend on data. Information is wealth. You will be on the upper hand to negotiate prices with the seller and also the contractor especially when it comes to labor costs. Depending with your budget you will be able to pick the most pleasant roofing material. Are you planning to re-roof or install a roof to your new home? I guess you are already armed with everything you need. Go ahead and give your house a perfect roof.

Ensure you watch the you tube video. The video comprises of very essential information. The eLearning video will explain further the differences between the two roof materials .The info will ensure you eliminate all the myths you have heard about either of the roofs.

For more information on metal and asphalt roofing, you can visit